A few years ago, a cyber insurance application was a short form. Today it reads more like a checklist. Insurers want to know how you log in, how you back up, and what protects your computers.
If you run a small office or a church, you probably don't have an IT department to translate it. That's fine. This guide walks through the 12 questions our free self-check asks, which are based on what insurers commonly ask. For each one you get four things:
- What the question means
- What a real "yes" requires
- The fix
- What proof to keep
One rule before we start. Always answer the application truthfully. A wrong answer can give the insurer a reason to deny a claim, right when you need it most. The goal is not to find a way to check "yes." The goal is to make "yes" true.
Want your own score first? Take the free self-check. It's 12 questions, takes about 5 minutes, and needs no credit card.
1. Do all users need MFA to log in to email?
What it means. MFA (multi-factor authentication) means a second step after the password, like a text code or an authenticator app. Think of it as a deadbolt on top of the door lock. A stolen password alone no longer gets someone in.
What a real "yes" requires. Every user. Not just the boss, not just most staff. That includes the shared front desk inbox, the volunteer coordinator, and the account nobody has used since last spring. If even one mailbox can be opened with only a password, the honest answer is "partly."
The fix. Turn on MFA for every email account. This is one of the most common insurer requirements.
Proof to keep. A screenshot of the MFA setting in your email admin panel (Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace), plus a list of every account showing MFA is on. Write down any exceptions and why they exist.
Check where you stand on MFA with the free self-check.
2. Is MFA required for all remote access (VPN, remote desktop, cloud apps)?
What it means. Remote access is any way to reach your systems from outside the office. A VPN, remote desktop to the office PC, or cloud apps like your accounting or donor software all count. If you have no remote access at all, the answer is "yes."
What a real "yes" requires. Every door from the outside has the second lock. That means the VPN, any remote desktop connection, and each cloud app your team signs in to from home or a phone. One forgotten path is enough to make the answer "partly."
The fix. Require MFA on every remote access path, or shut off the ones you don't use.
Proof to keep. A short list of every remote access path you have, with a note and screenshot showing MFA is required on each one. If you shut something off, note the date.
See how your remote access scores in the free self-check.
3. Do admin and IT accounts use MFA?
What it means. Admin accounts are the ones that can change settings, add users, or manage servers. They hold the master keys.
What a real "yes" requires. Every account with admin power has MFA. That includes your email admin, your website or domain account, the router or firewall login, and any account your IT helper uses. These are the accounts attackers want most, because one admin account can open everything else.
The fix. Put MFA on every admin account. Attackers go after these first.
Proof to keep. A list of every admin account and who owns it, with a screenshot showing MFA on each. Update it whenever someone joins, leaves, or gets new access.
Take the free self-check to see if your admin accounts are covered.
4. Do you keep backups offline or separate from your network, and have you tested a restore in the last 6 months?
What it means. This question is really two questions. First, is there a backup that ransomware can't reach? Second, do you have proof it actually works?
A backup that sits on the same network as your computers is like keeping your spare house key on the same ring as your main key. If someone takes the ring, both are gone. Ransomware can lock or wipe backups it can reach.
What a real "yes" requires. At least one copy of your important files lives offline or separate from your network. "Immutable" backups, which can't be changed or deleted for a set time, also fit here. And you have actually restored files from that backup in the last 6 months and confirmed they open. A backup you have never tested is a hope, not a backup.
The fix. Set up offline or immutable backups and test a restore. Write down the date.
Proof to keep. A one-line log of each restore test: the date, what you restored, who did it, and whether it worked. Keep a screenshot of the backup settings too.
Find out if your backups would pass with the free self-check.
5. Do all computers and servers have up-to-date endpoint protection (EDR or modern antivirus)?
What it means. EDR (endpoint detection and response) watches for suspicious behavior, not just known viruses. Old antivirus checks files against a list of known bad ones, like a guard with a wanted poster. EDR is more like a guard who notices when someone is acting wrong, even a stranger.
What a real "yes" requires. Every computer and server has it, it is up to date, and it is actually reporting in. The old laptop in the back office counts. So does the PC in the church sound booth.
The fix. Install EDR or a managed antivirus on every device and confirm it is reporting.
Proof to keep. A list of every device, plus a screenshot from your security tool's dashboard showing each one is protected and checked in recently.
See how your devices score in the free self-check.
6. Are Windows, Mac, and key software updates installed within about 30 days?
What it means. Updates fix security holes that attackers already know about. This includes browsers, Office, and firewalls or routers, not just Windows and Mac.
What a real "yes" requires. Updates land within about 30 days of release on every device. That includes the router and firewall, which are easy to forget because they sit in a closet and never ask for anything.
The fix. Turn on automatic updates and check monthly for anything that didn't install.
Proof to keep. A screenshot showing automatic updates are on, and a short monthly note of your check: the date and anything you had to fix by hand.
Take the free self-check to see where updates stand.
7. Do you filter email for spam, phishing, and bad attachments?
What it means. Most attacks start with an email. A filter catches the fake invoice, the phony "pastor needs gift cards" message, and the poisoned attachment before anyone clicks. Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace include filtering, but settings matter.
What a real "yes" requires. Filtering is on and set up properly, including phishing and attachment protection. Having Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace is a good start, but the real answer depends on how the settings are configured.
The fix. Review your email security settings and turn on phishing and attachment protection.
Proof to keep. Screenshots of your email security settings showing phishing and attachment protection turned on, with the date you checked.
Check your email protection with the free self-check.
8. Has everyone had phishing or security awareness training in the last year?
What it means. Your people are part of your defense. Training teaches them to spot a fake email or a scam text before they act on it. Short videos or simulated phishing emails count.
What a real "yes" requires. Everyone, in the last year. For a church, that includes volunteers who use church email or handle money. Training that only the office manager took does not make the answer "yes."
The fix. Run a short training for all staff and volunteers, and keep a record of who finished.
Proof to keep. A list of who finished the training and when. A simple spreadsheet works. If you run simulated phishing emails, save the results.
See how training scores in the free self-check.
9. Do people use normal (non-admin) accounts for everyday work?
What it means. Admin rights only when needed, on separate accounts. If you browse the web and read email while logged in as an admin, one bad click can do admin-level damage.
Think of it like a church building. Most people get a key to the front door. Only a few get the key to the office safe, and they don't carry it around all day.
What a real "yes" requires. Daily work happens on normal accounts. Anyone who needs admin power has a second, separate admin login and uses it only for admin tasks.
The fix. Remove admin rights from daily accounts. Use a separate admin login only when needed.
Proof to keep. A list of who has admin rights and their separate admin account names. Screenshots of each computer's user list showing daily accounts are standard users.
Take the free self-check to see if your accounts are set up right.
10. Do you have a written plan for what to do if you get hacked or hit by ransomware?
What it means. An incident response plan covers who to call, what to shut off, and how to reach your insurer. It's a fire escape plan for your computers. You hope you never use it, but you don't want to write it while the building is burning.
What a real "yes" requires. It is written down, not just in someone's head. People know where it is. It works even if the computers are down, so keep a printed copy.
The fix. Write a simple one-page incident response plan with names and phone numbers.
Proof to keep. The plan itself, with the date it was last updated. Keep a printed copy somewhere safe and note who has a copy.
Check your readiness with the free self-check.
11. Do outside vendors or IT helpers use secure, approved remote access that you can turn off?
What it means. Your IT helper, software vendor, or copier company may connect to your systems from outside. This question asks whether that access is controlled. Not shared passwords or always-on remote tools.
What a real "yes" requires. You know every vendor who has access. Each one has their own login with MFA. You can turn their access off, and you remove it when the work ends. Handing out the same password to everyone is like giving copies of your house key to every contractor you've ever hired.
The fix. List every vendor with access, give each its own login with MFA, and remove old access.
Proof to keep. A vendor access list: who, what they can reach, how they log in, and the date you last reviewed it. Note the date you removed any old access.
See how vendor access scores in the free self-check.
12. Are laptops and devices with sensitive data encrypted?
What it means. Encryption scrambles the data on a device so a thief can't read it without the password. On Windows it's called BitLocker. On a Mac it's called FileVault.
What a real "yes" requires. Every laptop and device with sensitive data has encryption turned on. Think member lists, giving records, client files, and payroll. Laptops leave the building, get left in cars, and get stolen. Encryption turns a stolen laptop into a hardware loss instead of a data breach.
The fix. Turn on BitLocker or FileVault on every laptop with sensitive data.
Proof to keep. A list of laptops with a screenshot from each showing BitLocker or FileVault is on. Store the recovery keys somewhere safe, separate from the laptops.
Take the free self-check to see your full score.
What if you're not sure?
"Not sure" is an honest answer on a self-check. It is not a good answer on an insurance application. Insurers expect a clear answer, so find out before you apply.
Some insurers ask you to prove your answers, at renewal or after a claim. That is why the "proof to keep" lines above matter. A screenshot and a dated note today can save a hard conversation later.
Answer truthfully, then make the truth better
Always answer insurance applications truthfully and completely. If the honest answer today is "no" or "partly," say so. Then fix it before renewal so next time the honest answer is "yes."
CyberDefense Consulting is not an insurance agency or broker. We don't sell insurance, recommend policies, or give insurance advice, and we can't promise coverage or a lower price. Only your insurer decides that. Your agent or broker handles the policy. We help you understand the security questions and get your systems ready.
Your next step
Start with the free self-check. Take it here. 12 questions, about 5 minutes, no credit card. You get a score and a plain-language list of gaps.
Want help with your real application? Book a Readiness Review. We go through your actual insurer application with you, line by line. You get a one-page fix list in priority order, a short list of the proof to keep for each yes, and a 30-minute call to walk through it. It's $299, or $199 for churches and nonprofits.
Need the fixes done? The full Cyber Insurance Readiness project is a flat $1,497. We work the application question by question until each answer is a truthful yes, or we hand you a written gap plan with costs. Hands-on work is quoted at our normal project rates before any work starts.
Want help every year? Stay Ready is $39 a month for renewal reminders, a quarterly check-in, and help with the questionnaire at renewal. Cancel anytime.
CyberDefense Consulting is based in Indio, in the Coachella Valley, California. We are a Service-Disabled Veteran-Owned Small Business, certified by the U.S. Small Business Administration. Call us at (760) 848-0202, Monday to Friday, 10:30 AM to 5 PM Pacific.
Take the free self-check | See the Readiness Review
If you run a church, the plain-English church checklist covers shared mailboxes, volunteers who leave, and pastor impersonation.
CyberDefense Consulting LLC is not an insurance broker or agent and does not provide insurance advice. We do not guarantee coverage, approval, or premium amounts. Coverage decisions are made only by your insurer. Always answer insurance applications truthfully and completely. Our services are IT and security readiness consulting only.